Free Home Delivery for Most Orders Over $149 + Subscribe and Save 5% Storewide + Additional Savings for In Store Pickup

January Subscribe & Save Sale

This Month Only: Purchase a subscription and get 2 FREE burger patties in every subscription until you cancel.

Plus save 5% — edit, skip, or cancel anytime

This Month Only: Free Burgers

  • Two FREE 1/4 lb patties in every subscription
  • Included in every order until you cancel

Save 5% On Every Order

  • No member fees or commitments
  • Easy 1-click opt-in at checkout
  • 5% savings applies storewide

100% Customizable

  • Shop our entire store (200+ items)
  • Customize your repeating schedule
  • Edit, skip or cancel anytime

Customer FAQs

How do I sign up for Subscribe & Save?

During checkout, just select the “Subscribe & Save” checkbox and follow the instructions to complete the setup.

How do I cancel my Subscribe & Save subscription?

Go to “Account” in the top right corner of our homepage, select the “Subscribe & Save” dropdown, and scroll down to the bottom of the page to click the “Cancel Subscription” button.

How do I skip a Subscribe & Save order?

Go to “Account” in the top right corner of our homepage, select the “Subscribe & Save” dropdown, and hit the “Skip” button on the top right of page. This will cancel your current order and push your subscription to the next scheduled delivery.

How do I get my Subscribe & Save order sooner?

Go to “Account” in the top right corner of our homepage, select the “Subscribe & Save” dropdown, and click the “Reschedule" button. You can then choice from the available delivery dates to get your order sooner. 

How do I add or remove items from my Subscribe & Save order?

Your current order will be displayed in the cart. You can add or remove items as needed. Any changes will automatically update, and you’ll only receive one confirmation email. If you make further changes after that, they will be reflected in the final order confirmation email.

How do I change my address?

Please reach out to support@buckeyevalleybeef.com for any address updates.

How do I change my delivery date?

Log in and select “Subscribe & Save” from the Account menu. From there, you’ll be able to select a new delivery date that works better for you.

What if I need to skip or cancel my order?

You have full control over your subscription. You can modify your order, skip a delivery, or cancel anytime. We won’t lock you into any commitments, and we’ll never make you hunt for a cancellation button — we don’t like those either!

Will I be notified before each delivery?

Absolutely! You’ll receive an email 2-3 days before your order leaves our farm, and another reminder on the day of your deadline to make changes closes.

How long do I have to adjust or change my Subscribe & Save order?

You can make changes to your order up until the cutoff deadline for your area. You’ll receive an email and text the week before your deadline to remind you to make any adjustments.

How do I change my Subscribe & Save order frequency?

Log in and select "Subscribe & Save" from the Account menu. From there, you can choose a delivery frequency that works best for you, whether it’s weekly, every two weeks, every four weeks, or every six weeks.

How do I send a gift to someone else under my account?

Simply reach out to us for assistance. We'll be happy to manually enter your gift order.

Testimonials

We picked up our 1/4 beef share in mid/late June 2025 and decided to increase our next order to a 1/2 beef share which we will pick up in January. Quality of the beef is excellent and staff was friendly the whole way through!
Katie G.
We've purchased local beef from several different farms. This one is our favorite! It is extremely high quality, phenomenal taste, and excellent packaging. Not only that, their communication was outstanding. Highly recommend!
Daniel R.
Fast delivery of the best beef money can buy.....Buckeye Valley has helped us keep our freezer stocked...year in year out.
Gerald D.

Need Inspiration? Try these boxes on subscription.

Best of Buckeye

Approx. 19 lbs | Beef, Chicken & Pork

Save $27.41
$200.00
$227.41
Save $25.75
$295.00
$320.75
Save $4.96
$49.99
$54.95
Save $23.00
$207.50
$230.50
Save $8.50
$200.00
$208.50
Save $44.00
$185.00
$229.00

Get Started

Sign Up & Shop

Create your free account and choose the pickup location closest to you. This is where/how you will receive your order.

1-Click Subscribe

Click Subscribe & Save at checkout to receive 5% savings + your free item.

Customize Anytime

You receive notices so that you can add to, modify, or skip your order - anytime!

Our Promise to You

We deliver premium-quality meat with complete transparency. Have questions about our practices or need cooking advice? We’re here to help.

What You Can Expect from Buckeye Valley Beef:

  • âś” Flash-frozen at the peak of freshness
  • âś” No hormones, antibiotics, or steroids
  • âś” Free from dyes, fillers, and artificial flavorings
  • âś” Raised on Ohio pastures & hills for most of their lives
  • Farm website & online store provided by GrazeCart